In recent
years I've had a flat-line reaction
when I hear
news that a handful of veteran activists have managed, yet again,
to gain access to a nuclear submarine or to a nuclear missile silo
on which they have hammered out their outrage or spilled sorrowful
blood. Such dogged, often sacrificial, devotion to keeping the threat
of nuclear war - and the expense of nuclear deterrence - before
the public's eyes has value, I know. But although I spent a lot
of time in the 1980s vigiling and protesting outside nuclear weapons
manufacturers, at the Pentagon and on the steps of a variety of
federal government buildings, I have lately had no wish to praise
or follow. The shrill drama has seemed disconnected from real life,
somehow, although I'll admit that I've had difficulty explaining
why.
So,
when I journeyed to Las Vegas
to participate
in the Healing Global Wounds' "Honor Your Mother Gathering"
at the Nevada Test Site (NTS) last spring, I wasn't much tempted
by the organizers' promise that there would be a chance to participate
in one or more acts of civil disobedience. But I was to experience
a change of heart.
The shift began
with a forum on nuclear issues hosted by the Episcopal Peace Fellowship,
where I was startled to discover that although the audience seemed
uniformly in favor of nuclear abolition, at least half the group
thought non-military applications of nuclear technology were probably
acceptable. As one presenter expressed it, "If the world is
going to have an industrial-based society, nuclear energy is the
best way to go."
That session
offered a useful reminder of a prevailing mind-set: Continuing to
develop and deploy weapons of mass destruction seems obviously undesirable
and probably immoral. But maybe, just maybe, now that we have the
means to profitably utilize the power of the atom, it would be imprudent
to repudiate peacetime applications altogether.
How is it,
I found myself wondering
that mass destruction
delivered by nuclear missiles seems to so many a clearer evil than
mass destruction delivered by a corporation or a utility company
or a government corps of engineers?
For the next
two days I had plenty of chance to chew on that conundrum at the
Healing Global Wounds campsite near the Mercury, Nev., gate into
the NTS. Here the desert vistas are vast, the ground rocky and the
vegetation sparse. For centuries this has been Western Shoshone
land, as recognized by the U.S. government in the Treaty of Ruby
Valley in 1863. It was in 1948 that the U.S. forcibly removed over
100 Shoshone familes from the Rhode Island-size area it wanted for
the NTS, marked now by the barbed wire fence we could see across
the highway.
"Be aware
that the desert around you
is extremely
fragile," gathering organizers cautioned. "While we may
be camped in an area that looks free of wildlife, it's not. Many
animals and plants make this their home. Don't move rocks or rip
out bushes. Whole ecosystems live under them."
Avoiding washes
or "very dusty looking low areas" was also recommended,
since "the dangerous fallout from above-ground testing tends
to accumulate in these areas."
Just visible
on the horizon was Yucca Mountain, a site within the NTS of sacred
importance to a variety of tribal groups in the region. Its future
as a storage facility for spent reactor fuel is being hotly contested
and the forces in favor are formidable. A Healing Global Wounds
information sheet noted that the NTS is already the dumping ground
for nuclear waste from clean-up efforts at other nuclear weapons
facilities, though the clean-up budget here is small. A nuclear
dump down the road near Beatty, Nev., reportedly is leaking into
the groundwater after only 20 years.
The land, it
takes little imagination to see, doesn't distinguish between the
peaceful or aggressive intentions that lead to its poisoning. Its
distress only spreads and deepens as we stockpile against possible
attack, as generators hum.
Both the U.S.
federal government and the Western Shoshone people claim sovereignty
over this territory. One considers it expendable, useful largely
as a huge toxic dumping ground. The other cherishes its wildness
and seeks its healing.
The thought,
very simply, pushed me over the edge.
I knew I wouldn't
be able to leave this place without making some clear witness on
behalf of the forces of life, some embodied response to the land's
fierce but fragile beauty and the indifference with which it has
been violated.
And so, on Mother's
Day, clutching a yellow permit issued by the Western Shoshone authorizing
my passage onto their land, I joined with 197 others in entering the
NTS. I didn't feel righteous or courageous. I did, however, feel in
dep solidarity with real life. I could feel it under my feet.